Paging Dr. Hamblin: Is It Safe to See My Therapist in Person?


The profit could very effectively outweigh any minor threat. But it’s all in the way you do it.

James Hamblin

Julian Montague

Editor’s Note: On Wednesdays, James Hamblin takes questions from readers about health-related curiosities, considerations, and obsessions. Have one? Email him at

Dear Dr. Hamblin,

I have to see my therapist, however she isn’t doing teletherapy as a result of her listening to. She says she’s opening home windows on each side of her workplace, leaving one hour between appointments, requiring masks, and swapping the nylon cowl on the sofa between purchasers. I nonetheless don’t really feel snug. Plus, she herself is aged. Am I overreacting?


San Francisco, California

San Francisco,

You are overreacting. Because I’m not a therapist, I’ll let you know that straight, although I perceive it might be more practical to allow you to uncover it your self.

It’s good to be cautious. About 1,700 Americans are dying from COVID-19 on daily basis. The quantity is climbing rapidly. Our collective downside is that most individuals aren’t being cautious sufficient. At the identical time, it stays doable to be too cautious. At a sure level, warning turns into self-defeating, particularly if it means lacking issues like vital medical appointments.

When in-person visits can moderately be delayed till vaccination is widespread, that could be the most secure selection, particularly in locations the place health-care programs are overwhelmed. Many people who find themselves younger and wholesome, for instance, could possibly be advantageous with out an annual primary-care check-up this yr. But maintaining with remedy is extraordinarily vital, extra like a root canal than a wart removing, and much more so at a second when the United States is seeing a surge in mental-health points.

Recommended Reading

In your case, it feels like your therapist is doing virtually all the things proper. She’s arrange good airflow (assuming these are huge home windows, significantly open) and required folks to put on masks (assuming these are good masks, worn effectively). Clinicians world wide have managed to see sufferers safely underneath comparable circumstances, and even to deal with individuals who have COVID-19 (which neither of it is best to knowingly have). I’m undecided in regards to the necessity of adjusting the sofa cowl or ready a full hour between appointments, however the measures she’s taking counsel meticulousness, which itself is a reassuring signal.

The primary precept to remember—for this form of appointment and others prefer it—is that you just need to ensure you’re in an area the place the coronavirus can’t accumulate within the air. If one individual is contaminated and speaking in an enclosed area, the air within the room can step by step fill with virus. Masks assist this occur extra slowly, and airflow helps dilute the buildup of virus (although neither completely prevents it). Taken collectively, efficient masks and excessive airflow make it extraordinarily unlikely that you just’ll be uncovered to sufficient virus to contaminate you (or that you just’ll infect your therapist). If her workplace is gigantic, like an airplane hangar, then the danger is actually zero. In a small workplace, an identical impact may be achieved with an air air purifier that has a HEPA filter, which might clear the air of any virus each jiffy.

All of that stated, I do know the futility of telling somebody who’s nervous to not be nervous. Anxiety isn’t mitigated by a barrage of details about airflow and viral doses. If you’re feeling uncomfortable within the workplace, your classes will likely be much less efficient. The complete course of requires you to really feel comfortable within the setting and to focus in your ideas and feelings.

So if I’ve didn’t reassure you right here, and also you’re not going to have the ability to comfortably see this therapist, then please attempt to discover some assist on-line. If you might have a long-standing relationship with this therapist, seeing somebody new could really feel daunting, like ranging from scratch. Establishing a relationship with a brand new therapist—particularly one you’ve solely ever met on-line—can take time. They have to get to know you, and to see how your pondering and moods fluctuate from week to week, to be maximally efficient. Even in case your state of affairs doesn’t really feel pressing in the intervening time, we’re on the cusp of an extended, darkish winter. Ideally everybody would have entry to inexpensive remedy on the prepared. If you’re one of many lucky who does, don’t wait till it’s an emergency to get began.

“Paging Dr. Hamblin” is for informational functions solely, doesn’t represent medical recommendation, and isn’t an alternative choice to skilled medical recommendation, analysis, or therapy. Always search the recommendation of your doctor or different certified well being supplier with any questions you could have relating to a medical situation. By submitting a letter, you’re agreeing to let The Atlantic use it—partly or in full—and we could edit it for size and/or readability.

You may also like...