RHR: The Well being Advantages of Tocotrienols, with Dr. Barrie Tan

On this episode, we focus on:

  • The distinction between tocopherols and tocotrienols
  • Tan’s discovery of tocotrienols in annatto
  • Early research on tocotrienols
  • Advantages of tocotrienols on ldl cholesterol
  • Advantages of tocotrienols on cardiovascular and metabolic well being
  • Advantages of tocotrienols on irritation and oxidative stress
  • Advantages of tocotrienols on most cancers prevention and remedy
  • Methods to finest make the most of tocotrienols

Present notes:

  • Barrie Tan’s web site
  • Tan is providing our listeners the chance to obtain his e book The Reality About Vitamin E without cost. Go to barrietan.com/e book and enter the code Revolution Well being on your free copy.
  • Obtain your well being targets and dwell your finest life with Adapt Naturals. Be part of the e-mail checklist at chriskresser.com for the newest updates on the July launch of the Core Plus bundle.

Hey, all people, Chris Kresser right here. Welcome to a different episode of Revolution Well being Radio. About 10 years in the past, once I created the Excessive Ldl cholesterol Motion Plan, which is a digital training program for individuals with lipid abnormalities, I got here throughout in my analysis substances known as tocotrienols. They’re a type of vitamin E, however not the most typical kind that you simply’ve in all probability heard of. You probably have a multivitamin or a complement that has vitamin E in it, chances are high it’s tocopherol, alpha-tocopherol, particularly. And it seems that tocopherols, regardless that they’re one of the best recognized type of vitamin E, have some downsides.

Research have proven over time that supplementing with alpha-tocopherol might enhance the chance of most cancers and coronary heart illness and trigger different issues. Whereas tocotrienols, which aren’t as well-known and had been solely found within the Nineteen Sixties and [were] clearly distinguished from tocopherols within the early 2000s, simply 20 years in the past, are way more useful as a household of dietary compounds and have proven fairly exceptional impacts when it comes to discount in cardiovascular threat components, metabolic threat components like glucose and insulin, inflammatory markers, like C-reactive protein and interleukin-6, and a variety of most cancers prevention advantages and doubtlessly even most cancers remedy. So it’s an thrilling household of compounds, and, as I mentioned, I stumbled throughout them a couple of decade in the past once I was researching pure approaches for reducing [low-density lipoprotein] (LDL) particle quantity, thus lowering heart problems threat. I discovered [that] delta- and gamma-tocotrienols are one of many few pure substances that had been recognized to try this. I’ve been conscious of those compounds for a few years and [am] utilizing them in my scientific observe. However I spotted not too long ago that I had by no means carried out a podcast on tocotrienols, and I don’t imagine that I’ve ever written a full weblog article on them both. So that is my try and treatment that.

With the intention to try this, I requested one of many foremost specialists on tocotrienols on the planet to affix me on the present, Dr. Barrie Tan. Dr. Tan really found the tocotrienol content material in annatto. He was in South America and was a pioneer on this subject. He earned his PhD in chemistry and biochemistry from the College of Otago in New Zealand after which spent a number of years as a professor at [the] College of Massachusetts. His work is concentrated on lipid-soluble vitamins that influence persistent circumstances, and he was the primary to introduce the advantages of tocotrienols to the vitamin trade and the primary to develop a tocopherol-free tocotrienol product that was derived from annatto, which he found. He didn’t uncover annatto, after all, however he found that annatto was a supply solely of delta- and gamma-tocotrienols.

I used to be actually excited to have the possibility to speak with Dr. Tan, as I’ve recognized of his work for a few years, and to listen to his fascinating story [about] the invention of tocotrienols in annatto, and all of the superb analysis that he has carried out since then and remains to be doing on the advantages of tocotrienols on every thing from osteoporosis and bone well being to metabolic circumstances to discount of the chance of most cancers. So I hope you get pleasure from this interview as a lot as I did. Let’s dive in.

Chris Kresser:  Dr. Tan, welcome to the present. It’s such a pleasure to have you ever on.

Barrie Tan:   Thanks. [I] like to be doing this, and I’m glad to be [on] your present.

The Distinction between Tocopherols and Tocotrienols

Chris Kresser:  I need to dive proper in and speak about a little bit little bit of historical past right here. A number of listeners will likely be conscious that vitamin E is an antioxidant, and so they might have heard again within the ‘70s, ‘80s, ‘90s even, and to this present day, in some circles, [that] there’s been an enormous advice to complement with vitamin E to enhance your antioxidant standing. However a number of years in the past, there have been some disturbing research concerning the long-term results of supplementing with vitamin E. And we’re, after all, going to get extra clear about what we’re really speaking about once we say “vitamin E.” However there have been some disturbing research that confirmed that long-term supplementation with larger doses of vitamin E may really enhance the chance of most cancers and coronary heart illness and trigger different issues. And I feel lots of people received turned off to the idea of vitamin E supplementation.

I actually wrote about these research a few years in the past and was involved concerning the influence of long-term supplementation with vitamin E. Then a number of years later, [I] found that, relating to vitamin E, there are literally two totally different varieties, and so they’re very totally different of their organic impact on the physique. You had been instrumental on this subject in making these discoveries and actually advancing the data of one of many isomers of vitamin E, tocotrienol, which we’ll be speaking about right now. Are you able to inform us a little bit little bit of your story and the way you stumbled throughout tocotrienols and received all in favour of their organic results?

Barrie Tan:  Effectively, thanks for that great introduction. Because you talked about that vitamin E within the final 20 years has carried out extra hurt than good, for instance, in some cancers, and in girls in lots of [ways]. If you get an opportunity to obtain my e book, I describe all these totally different [ways where] vitamin E could possibly be troublesome. That troublesome vitamin E is referring to alpha-tocopherol as a result of alpha-tocopherol was [the] first to be found, and, subsequently, you’ve an extended historical past of utilization. Simply [to] preserve the story easy, the explanation alpha-tocopherol [has] carried out injury is that this: there are eight vitamin Es, 4 tocopherols and 4 tocotrienols, and so they’re all antioxidants due to the top. It has an O-H group that [is] antioxidant. The one distinction between the tocopherol as a gaggle and the tocotrienol as a gaggle [is that] the tocotrienols have three double bonds within the tail, therefore “trien.”

So the tail is a little bit bit shorter, and, in simplistic phrases, the shorter tail permits it to insert into the cell membrane, and it will possibly circle round going a lot quicker to seize free radicals, and therefore is a stronger antioxidant. Tocopherol can’t try this. [But] that doesn’t clarify why tocopherol is poisonous or doubtlessly could possibly be when you take large quantities.

The reason being as a result of the alpha-tocopherol has a transport protein, that means that it has a chaperone to make sure it’s coming into into the physique. When individuals take 400 milligrams, [or] 1000 milligrams, and even 2000 milligrams, an enormous quantity goes in, is conserved, and it’s not popping out. The tocotrienol[s] don’t have any such luck. The physique solely takes no matter it wants, [and] no matter it doesn’t isn’t going to go in. So that will be the principle purpose [for] one in comparison with the opposite.

Dr. Tan’s Discovery of Tocotrienols in Annatto

So now, [here’s] the story. I went to South America about 25 years in the past to search for lutein. I’m certain you’ve interviewed different individuals on lutein for the macula. On the time, it was 1989, 1990. Only a few individuals [had] heard about lutein. I [had] as a result of my whole research once I was an assistant professor on the College of Massachusetts was on carotenoid. They’re unconjugated double bonds, so I studied beta-carotene, alpha-carotene, lycopene, [and] astaxanthin.

Chris Kresser:   These are actually phrases that everyone has heard of, however again in 1989, they had been unfamiliar, proper?

Barrie Tan:   Yeah.

Chris Kresser:   So that you had been down in South America searching for a supply of lutein? Is that what you had been doing?

Barrie Tan:  Yeah, a supply of lutein. [I was there with that] aim, and I [found it]. However destiny has it that actually 30 ft away from me, I noticed these lovely annatto crops.

I used to be in South America then, and subsequently, I’ve been to many nations. I noticed this plant. Consider a fruit that you simply eat; you’ll at all times have a fleshy half. The place the fleshy half is on this fruit, the pod is the fruit. After I opened the pod [of the annatto], the fleshy half [was] air. So it’s a really uncommon fruit in that it doesn’t have a mesocarp, in contrast to papaya, apple, pear, oranges, [and] every thing else. [It’s] simply empty, and if you contact it, it stains your hand. [The] British nickname is the lipstick plant as a result of it stains your hand, and immediately, I knew that [it] was a carotene.

Now, that is [a] lengthy [time ago]. I knew that, amongst chemical substances, in all probability one of the vital unstable natural chemical substances is carotene. Not omega-3, by a longshot. If you understand omega-3 is unstable, this will likely be way more unstable. Now in life, if you see carotene like beta-carotene in carrot, [and] lycopene in tomato, you need to put it in a sauce and switch the warmth up. I’m really telling you one thing easy, however you get the gist. It’s a must to prepare dinner it earlier than you’ll be able to see the oil turning coloration. That signifies that the carotene is well-preserved contained in the cytoplasm. Particular person cells of every of these. In the event you dwell in New England, [like] the place I’m [at] in Massachusetts, suppose [of a] lobster, suppose [of a] crustacean. They’re often greenish, yucky inexperienced, [or] bluish coloration. The second you prepare dinner them, [they] instantly turn out to be brilliantly orange or pink. That signifies that within the crustacean, they deprotonate and the carotene comes up. They’re well-preserved. All this to say [that] nature does it this fashion. That is the one exception to the rule. As a result of it’s not sure to something; it stains your hand. I’ve many ideas in life. Most of them come up in a useless finish. That is a kind of that didn’t useless finish. I assumed, “There should be a robust antioxidant that preserves this carotene from degradation.” Little did I do know, it was tocotrienol. I used to be guessing. It will be a polyphenol, this antioxidant. It was a pure stumbling on it; [I was] searching for carotene like lutein, after which I stumbled onto this roughly 20 to 25 years in the past.

Chris Kresser:   A really serendipitous accident.

Barrie Tan:   Sure.

Chris Kresser:  It turned out that you simply had chanced on a pure supply of delta- and gamma-tocotrienol. Whereas palm and rice and different sources of tocotrienols have a combination of delta- and gamma-tocotrienol [and] alpha- and beta-tocotrienol, that are much less potent, after which tocopherols, which might really intrude with the actions of tocotrienols, which we’ll come again to. Simply sticking with the historic view right here, tocopherols in vitamin E as a household had been found within the Nineteen Twenties or one thing. About 100 years in the past, proper?

Barrie Tan:  Sure.

Chris Kresser:  When was tocotrienol found? When was it found that tocopherol was not the one type of vitamin E?

Barrie Tan:  Truly, you touched on one thing auspicious, you [could] say. It’s precisely 100 years in the past [that] alpha-tocopherol was found by two pediatricians [at] UC Berkeley. It’s a very American affair. They extracted it and [saw] that with out the alpha-tocopherol, [a] fetus is unable to get to full time period. It’s exactly that [which] makes alpha-tocopherol and all of the tocopherols and tocotrienols a vitamin. It’s not due to its antioxidant property; it’s that. In any other case, [it would] by no means turn out to be a vitamin. In the event you quick ahead 40 years, [it] was concerning the Nineteen Sixties [when] the USDA lab and [a] College of Liverpool professor collectively collectively found [it]. On the time, they [didn’t] have chromatography. They noticed a shadow spot subsequent to the principle spot of alpha-tocopherol. For regular tocopherol, you’ve alpha, beta, delta, [and] gamma. Quite simple, 4 Greek letters. However when you have a look at previous literature, you will note nu, epsilon, zeta, and phi tocopherol. These nu-, epsilon-, beta-, and phi-tocopherol[s] had been mislabeled. They had been tocotrienol[s]. They only thought that they had been tocopherol[s].

Chris Kresser:  I see.

Barrie Tan:  You realize once they corrected that? Nearly within the 12 months 2000. They lastly [got] to appropriate it, after which they [became] correctly known as alpha-, beta-, delta-, and gamma-tocotrienol.

Chris Kresser:   You’re saying indirectly, they had been found again within the Nineteen Sixties. However they, at the moment, had been nonetheless believed to be a part of the tocopherol household, and so they weren’t correctly distinguished as a separate household known as tocotrienols—alpha, beta, delta, and gamma—till simply 20 years in the past, principally. A little bit over 20 years in the past.

Barrie Tan:  Isn’t that incredible?

Chris Kresser:  It’s superb.

Barrie Tan:   The explanation I received into that was [in the year] 1982, I used to be a lot youthful than I’m now and nonetheless residing in the identical place, Hadley, Massachusetts, two hours inland from Boston. I used to be an assistant professor at [the] College of Massachusetts, and it was there [that] I began to review palm and rice and found this. By that point, I already knew about these tocotrienols, [but] I wasn’t anticipating it in palm. After which I found [it] in palm.

So my timing of getting it isn’t by design, [but] by default. A lot of my life is like this. I occurred to be in the proper place learning palm oil, after which I occurred to be in South America searching for one thing else, and one thing [happened that] distracted me to do that. Now, my life and profession [rests] on this. There’s a lot on this tocotrienol that we’ve got [studied]. Given an opportunity, I can clarify later what we’ve got carried out in scientific trials and animal research on this. It will be superb if our viewers and listeners [did] not critically think about using this superb phytonutrient given to us by nature.

Chris Kresser:  Sure. As we had been speaking about earlier than we began the recording, I’ve been fascinated by tocotrienols and utilizing them in my observe for a few years, and have been stunned that not many clinicians find out about them and even fewer sufferers or particular person individuals find out about them. So I’m trying ahead to diving into the advantages of tocotrienols and the way they might help us optimize our well being on this trendy world that we’re residing in that, sadly, [has] so many threats when it comes to sources of irritation and oxidative stress and all the opposite challenges that we face.

Earlier than we try this, I need to look a little bit bit [at the fact that] tocotrienols had been a little bit disappointing at first for us within the analysis literature for what possibly was a shocking purpose. The early research on tocotrienols you talked about in your e book had been considerably disappointing. Why was that?

Early Research on Tocotrienols

Barrie Tan:  Early [on], I wasn’t the one particular person concerned in it. On the time, there [was] an abundance of tocotrienols that you might get from palm oil as a result of palm oil was accessible. Annatto was nowhere to be seen. I stumbled onto [that] nearly 20 years [later]. It was solely from palm oil, and coincidentally palm oil contained 25 % alpha-tocopherol. So once they gave it to animals [in] research, the ldl cholesterol and the lipids [of the animals] would drop. Then once they did scientific research someday later, they seen that [out of] 5 research, two labored and two didn’t and one [was] in between. So it’s 50/50. [There’s] no statistical something like that, so it was very disappointing. Then [a] College of Wisconsin professor and [I] mentioned, “Hey, we’ve received to seek out out why as a result of we can’t simply do numerous scientific research when it’s so equivocal.” So that they stopped scientific research. Meaning one other 15 years [had] been wasted. This [was] a really painful time for researchers. They stopped. They printed a seminal paper in 1997 that merely said [that] they had been guessing that the alpha-tocopherol isn’t innocuous, which they earlier presumed. Bear in mind, in nature, we thought [that] if one thing is sweet, then a symmetry, a mix of that’s good. Ordinarily, that’s true.

Chris Kresser:  Particularly in plant drugs, that’s often true, the place you’ve the total spectrum of compounds.

Barrie Tan:   Sure, that’s true. Now one has to ask, if the potential of synergism exists, then any rational pondering particular person must also settle for the likelihood [that] antagonism might also be there. Normally, it isn’t. However on this case, as an exception, it’s. So that they eliminated all of the alpha-tocopherols, they used the delta- and gamma- [tocotrienol, and] it work[ed] to decrease ldl cholesterol and decrease lipids. Then they used the identical quantity of tocotrienol, [but] they added in [a small] quantity of tocopherol, [and] they seen a slight drop, not too vital. In one other examine, they elevated the tocopherol, after which they noticed that the [tocotrienol] capacity to decrease ldl cholesterol [went] down, and ultimately, [they] elevated the quantity [of tocopherol until there was the] similar quantity of tocotrienol and tocopherol, and it fully inactivated the tocotrienol capacity to decrease ldl cholesterol.

So that they got here up with a conclusion that alpha-tocopherol mitigates or interferes with the operate of tocotrienol. Twenty-five years later, we’ve got systematically seen that when you add alpha-tocopherol, [it] not solely inhibits the flexibility of tocotrienol to decrease ldl cholesterol and lipid, [but] it additionally inhibits the tocotrienol capacity to go after most cancers and different persistent circumstances. So now we clearly know this.

Chris Kresser:  That was a tremendous discovery, and so useful when it comes to advancing the sector of analysis on the advantages of tocotrienols. I need to pause right here to make [it] clear [to] the listeners why that is such an essential discovery. Most multivitamins include alpha-tocopherol, and most dietary supplements that individuals would select off the shelf include alpha-tocopherol. So even when you had been to take tocotrienols individually, when you’re concurrently taking a excessive dose of supplemental tocopherol, you’re principally canceling out the potential advantages of these tocotrienols.

In your e book, you talked about that that is true for dietary supplements, however not true for the quantity of tocopherol that you’d get from a wholesome regular weight-reduction plan. So what’s the threshold? And when do individuals should be involved about their tocopherol consumption?

Barrie Tan:  In the event you take a traditional weight-reduction plan with regular vegetable oil and meat, as a result of the fats might include vitamin E, sometimes, one would get about 10 to fifteen milligrams of alpha-tocopherol on the most. And which may be mixed with different gamma-tocopherol, which has no sturdy vitamin E properties. However let’s say 10 to fifteen milligrams. At 10 to fifteen milligrams, when you had been to take 100 milligrams of tocotrienol, so the tocopherol is a couple of 10 to fifteen % proportion, the interference can be minuscule, if any. Generally individuals take about 300 milligrams, [making] the composition of alpha-tocopherol about 5 % or much less, [and] then [it] wouldn’t matter.

Be taught extra about tocotrienols and the superb potential they maintain to learn your well being, on this episode of Revolution Well being Radio #chriskresser #vitaminE #antioxidants

When it begins to matter is when it’s about 20 % and above, like 20 or 30 %. That might be if any person is taking 200 IU or 400 IU alpha-tocopherol or 1000 IU. In the event you take [that] a lot, then you definately fully swamp the flexibility of tocotrienol operate.

Advantages of Tocotrienols on Ldl cholesterol

Chris Kresser:   Let’s dive in now to the options of tocotrienols, maybe beginning with their cardiovascular protecting advantages. That’s how I first discovered of them, [when] I created a digital training program known as the Excessive Ldl cholesterol Motion Plan. My [clinical] observe was full, [and] I wasn’t in a position to see as many sufferers as I wished to, and I knew so many individuals had been fighting excessive ldl cholesterol and different lipid abnormalities. So I wished to create an academic program that condensed numerous what I had discovered in my analysis and [from] treating sufferers, and provides individuals [the] instruments that they may use safely on their very own to enhance their lipid profiles.

In my analysis, I had discovered concerning the essential distinction between LDL ldl cholesterol and LDL particles, and that LDL particles, in accordance with many lipidologists, are actually the driving drive behind coronary heart illness, not a lot ldl cholesterol. It’s within the particle, however the particle itself. The problem was [that] there was numerous analysis [and] rather a lot written on find out how to decrease ldl cholesterol, however there have been only a few substances, both prescribed drugs or pure substances, that had been proven to really decrease LDL particles. I discovered some research suggesting that delta- and gamma-tocotrienols may do that, and I began utilizing them in my observe and had superb outcomes. I noticed vital adjustments in LDL particle numbers, [apolipoprotein B] (ApoB) got here down, [and] I even noticed adjustments in lipoprotein(a), [Lp(a)], which is considered principally genetic and never modifiable by weight-reduction plan. After which I noticed C-reactive protein (CRP) come down. I noticed oxidized LDL come down due to their results as antioxidants. And I grew to become a tocotrienol convert. Inform us a little bit bit concerning the analysis on tocotrienols and lipids and different cardiovascular threat components.

Barrie Tan:   I feel what you simply talked about, LDL happening, particle dimension, and the oxidized LDL, [CRP], ApoB, LP(a), and [high-density lipoprotein] (HDL). We’ve carried out many research on it. However earlier than I dive into that, I simply need your viewers to know that [it] was some time again once we did that. In the present day, we’ve got lined, to the extent that we may, [using] tocotrienol on persistent circumstances. You possibly can ask me later what [the] totally different varieties [are]. However this was the primary one we went after. The second we went after was an enormous factor for me to chew, however I bit on it, and proper now, we’re nonetheless engaged on it. And that persistent situation is most cancers. We now have eight scientific trials in Denmark on most cancers. [I’m] enthusiastic about that. However alright, let’s get again to it.

Chris Kresser:  We will certainly speak about most cancers as a result of to me, that is among the most enjoyable potential functions of tocotrienol is [the] prevention and even perhaps remedy of most cancers. As everyone knows, that’s a rising drawback and one thing that we desperately want new therapeutic instruments for. So, sure, let’s come again to that. Perhaps we may discuss a little bit bit concerning the mechanism as a result of it is a fascinating factor about tocotrienols is [that] they cut back the exercise of HMG-CoA, which is identical enzyme that’s focused by statin medicine, which all people listening to this [show] is accustomed to. So possibly we may begin there.

Barrie Tan:   Because you talked about HMG-CoA, that may be a pathway for making ldl cholesterol, sure. And when you have a look at it, once more, they’ve a farnesyl group. In the event you look rigorously [at] the farnesyl group, it’s not so dissimilar from among the aspect chains of a statin drug, which is classically used for reducing ldl cholesterol. I do know the viewers isn’t this visually, [but] if I block away the O-H group, that complete factor is a farnesyl group. So if you take tocotrienol, the tocotrienol with the farnesyl group downregulates the HMG[-CoA] reductase enzyme, telling the liver to make much less of the reductase enzyme, and, subsequently, it’s making much less ldl cholesterol. So it’s a really light course of, and therefore, we’ve got by no means seen individuals complaining about muscle issues of any type or [coenzyme Q10] (CoQ10) drop of any type, [which] is a consequence of taking a statin drug. If this had been to be a tocopherol, I do know the viewers can’t see the place my finger is pointing [on the diagram], [but] there’s a double bond right here. One, two, and the final one is the place my pinky is, these three. In the event you take away the three double bonds, the tail will likely be a tocopherol, that’s not a farnesyl anymore. That’s a phytyl, and a phytyl is unable to downregulate the HMG[-CoA] reductase. Solely this farnesyl may. After which, whereas I’m at [it], this farnesyl tail is ideal. In the event you consider a cell membrane cell wall, of all pure substances which can be antioxidant, a tocotrienol is completely in a position to comfortable right into a membrane, and it’s there [that] it’s an antioxidant. In any other case, there are such a lot of antioxidants. Decide one. There’s resveratrol. Astaxanthin, very highly effective and well-known. They don’t seem to be going to compartmentalize right here. Why? Resveratrol, for instance, has 4 O-H teams, hydroxy teams, and astaxanthin has about two or three. So it’s a two-headed snake. All of the O-H teams [are] making it stick out. Nothing is ready to stick into the lipid membrane. This molecule, are you able to see [it]? The O-H group right here stands proud. This complete tail has to enter the membrane. I’ve by no means seen [this] in nature. There was an Austrian professor within the Eighties [who] determined to reply this query so way back. He determined that when you boil it down and extract all of the antioxidants from a cell, [then] what are these antioxidants developing on the very prime, which [is] about 90 % of it? They’re tocopherol and tocotrienol. And the remaining 10 [percent] are CoQ10 and a smidgen quantity of beta-carotene. [There’s] no point out of some other. They’re not there. They shield elsewhere, however not the cell. And the cell is what [needs] probably the most safety.

Chris Kresser:  Ultimately, I’d like to do a video podcast for that reason, so we will present individuals as an alternative of simply telling them.

I need to linger on a few issues right here as a result of I feel they’re actually, actually essential. The primary is that, in your e book, you discuss with the motion of tocotrienols and the HMG-CoA enzyme that statins have an effect on, as discriminate ldl cholesterol reducers. In different phrases, they do it in a approach that’s, you mentioned, extra light, but additionally extra [discriminating]. Whereas statins, if we may use an analogy, are extra of a sledgehammer when it comes to simply slamming the HMG-CoA enzyme in order that little or no ldl cholesterol is produced. And that, after all, has potential downsides.

In the event you inhibit that complete enzymatic pathway, you’re not simply lowering ldl cholesterol, you’re lowering CoQ10 and different essential substances that come out of that pathway. Whereas with tocotrienols, not solely have they got a extra light influence on that enzyme, [but] they don’t appear to intrude with CoQ10 manufacturing, and which will clarify why there are actually no uncomfortable side effects when taking tocotrienols in comparison with statins the place individuals can expertise, in some instances, fairly critical myopathy, sexual dysfunction, and even extreme issues like rhabdomyolysis in some uncommon instances. I feel that’s a very essential operate of tocotrienols that I need to make certain all people understands. The opposite piece of that is [that] it seems like tocotrienols don’t simply have an effect on ldl cholesterol; they’ll additionally cut back triglycerides, which is an important operate relating to each cardiovascular and metabolic well being. Do they try this? What’s the mechanism for that, the influence on the liver? However by means of a distinct pathway, I assume?

Advantages of Tocotrienols on Cardiovascular and Metabolic Well being

Barrie Tan:  The triglyceride pathway is much less studied than ldl cholesterol, and regardless that [it’s] much less studied, it [was] my understanding that it had larger scientific significance. We had been learning individuals who have excessive ldl cholesterol, [but] in any other case, not diabetic or pre-diabetic. However we constantly seen that the triglyceride dropped. The mechanism is [that] on tocopherol, the triglyceride drop and the triglyceride synthesis is one other pathway known as [sterol regulatory-element binding protein] (SREBP), another associated factor. I put it behind my head that the triglyceride dropped. I’ve been a member of the American Diabetes Affiliation for some 30 years, and I’ve [listened] to individuals time and again, to the totally different talks and mechanisms that they’ve. Normally, they search for some type of scientific endpoint. Then I by no means forgot Professor Gerald Reaven, [who] was about to retire, [and was] a medical physician endocrinologist from Stanford College. He was the one [who] famous within the mid-‘70s, late ‘80s that there [was] a cluster of metabolic issues. He [could] outline that the triglyceride went up earlier than they grew to become diabetic, [and] the sugar [went] up. [But] as a result of he couldn’t perceive find out how to bind all of them collectively, he known as it syndrome X, which later was outlined and is [now] known as metabolic syndrome. It was that gentleman who got here up with it. And now, until you’re older, you in all probability didn’t even realize it was known as syndrome X earlier than.

He informed me that earlier than individuals have hyperglycemia, their triglycerides go up first, and I received it in my head that hypertriglyceridemia precedes hyperglycemia. I by no means forgot it. So when any person is diabetic, they at all times have excessive triglyceride [in addition to] excessive sugar. However [in] any person who’s pre-diabetic, they’ve excessive triglyceride, [but] the sugar isn’t on the authorized restrict the place they’re diabetic. Due to the triglyceride difficulty, within the final 15 years, we’ve got carried out two to a few research on diabetes and pre-diabetes, and [also] three research on individuals with fatty liver illness. In diabetes and pre-diabetes, we constantly see that the administration of the lipids is managed and the sugar is below management. Once we say [the] sugar [is] below management, we measure it a little bit bit extra symptomatically than emotionally, so to talk. Emotionally means we’ll have a look at the fasting sugar the following day. It’s an essential quantity. A1C can be what maps the sugar within the final 90 days. However we went additional. We wished to see how that is with insulin. The American Diabetes Affiliation mentioned that you need to measure the insulin in addition to the sugar collectively. They name it the HOMA-IR, [which] is hemostasis [where] you have a look at the insulin and sugar collectively. Once we noticed that the HOMA-IR was in a position to drop, we knew for certain that [it] is controlling the sugar and in addition rising the sensitivity of the insulin.

Girls and gents, tocotrienol is ready to enhance the sensitivity of insulin. That’s large. With that, then you’ll be able to see that the management of the sugar is coming again. It’s from out of kilter to in kilter. I’m inspired by that. We went all out. My firm’s a small firm. We went all out [with] this examine. [We did a] three-month examine after which a six-month examine, end and publish and work. And now we’re finishing a 12-month examine on individuals with confirmed non-alcoholic fatty liver illness, which is one other aspect of metabolic syndrome. We noticed three issues. The irritation is in management, the liver enzyme [aspartate aminotransferase] (AST), [alanine aminotransferase] (ALT) is in management, the sugar, together with the HOMA-IR, is in management, [and] we even noticed that the extent of steatosis, the fats within the liver, and fibrosis, [are] additionally in management. Girls and gents, it is a dietary complement. I’m so thrilled as a result of roughly 25 to 30 % of People have fatty liver [disease]. You’ll take into consideration 30 years in the past, [this] type of cirrhotic liver would have come from alcohol ingesting. In fact, that also gained’t go away. However who would have guessed [that] by consuming [a] excessive quantity of fats, particularly saturated fats, it’s also possible to have [a] liver that appears cirrhotic like any person broken by alcohol.

Chris Kresser:  Yeah, and many processed and refined carbohydrates play an enormous function there with a non-alcoholic fatty liver, and people numbers proceed to go up, sadly, yearly. Having a pure and protected instrument to fight that’s simply exceptional. I do know out of your e book and from analysis that I’ve learn that the mechanism for a lot of of these advantages is considered [that] the tocotrienols activate [peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor-alpha] (PPAR-alpha), which is a protein that controls the genes which can be concerned with burning fatty acids for gas. This can be a protein that’s acquired numerous consideration within the analysis literature over the previous 10, 20 years as metabolic syndrome charges have skyrocketed and gone by means of the roof. It’s a goal of drug analysis and drug discovery. And right here, we’ve got a pure compound, an important vitamin, or a household of nutritional vitamins that may activate this compound, which is superb.

Barrie Tan:   Thanks for bringing that up. The PPAR, I generally overlook about that. It will increase the oxidation of the fatty acid to transform vitality. There’s PPAR, after which the opposite one is SREBP. It encourages [the] management [of] the synthesis of triglycerides. So one is controlling the triglyceride synthesis and the opposite one is changing the fatty acid to vitality. These are the 2 routes. I’ve not delved as a lot into the mechanism for the triglyceride one as I did with the ldl cholesterol one, as a result of I used to be so surprised by the [fact] that it’s in a position to management the triglycerides. So I went extra on the scientific aspect on this one. I answered the best way I did simply now. I imply, my goodness, it’s in a position to cut back scarring tissue of the liver and cut back fats storage within the liver. That’s large information. So I’m actually glad. Shortly sooner or later, I will likely be talking extra [in] these areas.

Advantages of Tocotrienols on Irritation and Oxidative Stress

Chris Kresser:   So I need to contact on a few different mechanisms, which I feel are essential as a result of they underlie all persistent, trendy illnesses, and people are irritation and oxidative stress, together with most cancers. We will use this as a segue to speak about most cancers and possibly briefly contact on bone well being on the best way as a result of that’s additionally a consequence of irritation. Tocotrienols are highly effective antioxidants, as you’ve talked about a number of occasions. I assumed it was fascinating in your e book that you simply talked about that alpha-tocopherol, which once more, is the shape that many individuals complement with, can really enhance the oxidation of LDL, whereas tocotrienols are reducing LDL oxidation and different types of oxidative stress. What’s occurring there?

Barrie Tan:   Sure, that examine was carried out by an oncologist in Chicago. As quickly as I [stumbled upon] that paper, nearly 15 years after it was printed, I desperately was making an attempt to contact this professor. She had moved on to San Francisco, and I [was] unable to succeed in her. Her examine was quite simple. She was treating girls with breast most cancers and heard that a lot of them [took] antioxidants, particularly alpha-tocopherol. She was in a position to get an institutional evaluate board to do a examine whereby they [took] tocopherol after which she [was] in a position to biopsy the tissue after which biopsy the tissue [again] one month after, so that you’ve got the cells to review these from the breast. These are girls with confirmed breast most cancers. She was anticipating to seek out that the alpha-tocopherol would supply sturdy antioxidative safety [and] that the most cancers cell [would] be [under] management and cut back injury. She discovered the precise reverse. It was fairly alarming. She discovered that as an alternative, there was no safety, and he or she noticed sure biochemical markers suggesting that the most cancers cell was proliferating. After I noticed the most cancers marker was proliferating, I went to have a look at tocotrienol on these most cancers markers [in] our research we did, after which I mentioned, “Oh my goodness; the tocotrienol is meant to go after these markers and nail it.” And that’s why the most cancers went away in breast most cancers, and there are various, many research like this.

However I used to be not in a position to contact her. I used to be in a position to dish out papers that present that when individuals give tocotrienol and it really works, after which they add again tocopherol systematically, it will possibly systematically and progressively and dose-dependently inactivate the flexibility of the tocotrienol to kill the breast most cancers. After that, they’ve carried out it with colon most cancers, prostate most cancers, and plenty of different cancers. All that to say, alpha-tocopherol can mitigate. However the one which this professor did was much more shocking. She didn’t [give] tocotrienol. She simply gave them alpha-tocopherol, and the alpha-tocopherol elevated [the cancer]. Unrelated to [that] examine, the Harvard examine reveals that [a] excessive consumption of alpha-tocopherol might even trigger most cancers. There it’s; I’m simply bearing it out.

If I say extra, it is going to appear to be I’m making an attempt to demonize alpha-tocopherol. I imagine when individuals [have] a traditional, nutritious diet [where they’re] attaining about 10 to fifteen milligrams of alpha-tocopherol, that’s adequate. In the event you complement vitamin E, please complement tocotrienol.

Chris Kresser:   I couldn’t agree extra. Science is a means of studying and frequently disproving our hypotheses and being prepared to confess once we had been fallacious, and hopefully, making higher selections going ahead.

Barrie Tan:  [I agree] 100%.

Chris Kresser:  With alpha-tocopherol, that’s the story. And that’s been the story with many, many different issues that appeared promising initially, after which turned out to be not so promising. We additionally generally tend on this nation, particularly, to suppose if a little bit little bit of one thing is sweet, then numerous it should be higher. And that’s not at all times the case, as we’ve discovered with alpha-tocopherol.

I need to contact briefly on the anti-inflammatory properties of tocotrienols as a result of these are fairly exceptional. Like I mentioned, and all people who listens to this present is aware of, irritation is on the root of all trendy illness[s]. So something that’s anti-inflammatory goes to, by definition, have a variety of impacts throughout a variety of inflammatory circumstances.

In your e book, you highlighted a number of of the research mentioning inhibition of nuclear issue kappa beta [(NF kappa B)] and [tumor necrosis factor] (TNF alpha), C-reactive protein, [methylmalonic acid] (MDA), and nitric oxide, that are pretty particular to heart problems however [are] additionally gamers in lots of different inflammatory circumstances. And that delta-tocotrienol has particularly been proven to scale back irritation and restore mobility in individuals with arthritis. They’ve additionally been proven to extend whole endogenous antioxidant standing. In order that’s a reasonably spectacular spectrum of anti-inflammatory actions.

Barrie Tan:   Sure. Now on this, you talked about a few of them, NF kappa B, tumor necrosis issue, [and] antioxidant standing. We constantly see these in animal research and in addition in scientific research. However I’d like to speak about irritation this fashion. I received onto this irritation factor as a result of [of] Paul Ridker.  He’s the particular person [who] popularized and underwrote the understanding of [CRP]. Professor Paul Ridker [is a] Harvard Medical Faculty professor. He spent 20, 25 years [publishing] so many research on [CRP]. When it’s all mentioned and carried out in your lipid panel, there is just one factor to search for to measure your CRP. That’s superb. And the way did he give you it? He mentioned that half the folks that have heart problems that turned actually unhealthy doubtlessly have excessive ldl cholesterol and oxidized LDL, such as you talked about earlier. However the different half of people that have cardiac arrest and issues like these have excessive irritation.

So he set out the trail to a dependable technique to examine irritation. This [CRP], which is about 30,000, 40,000 dimension molecular weight protein, that’s below stress, is being synthesized within the liver and oozing into the blood [and] you’ll be able to simply measure [it]. This irritation protein is also produced in case you have an an infection. So when you’ve an an infection, [and] you measure CRP, the quantity isn’t realistically significant. You need persistent irritation for which the CRP will do. So he did that, and we’ve got constantly sized [CRP] in individuals with hypercholesterolemia, in individuals [who] have excessive triglyceride, like pre-diabetes, in individuals who have diabetes, and now in a number of research in individuals [who] have fatty liver, their [CRP] constantly dropped. So in different phrases, a drop [in] irritation is essential and we see them. It might not be the smoking gun itself; it could possibly be the triglyceride drop and the [CRP] drop. So it could possibly be a hand in glove factor, unbiased of one another. Nevertheless, I need to contact on one other level.

I not too long ago heard Professor Ridker give a chat. Bear in mind, this gentleman has given 30 years of his life [to] doing  [CRP studies], and he mentioned one thing I seen that’s a small shift within the tectonic plate. I assumed you would possibly make notice of this and ask your different future interviewees. He mentioned that there are occasions apart from [CRP, that] there may be one other further marker, additionally below proper irritation, that will be actually hand in glove within the inflammatory factor. When he mentioned that, I simply stood up. He mentioned that [the] marker must be interleukin-6. He defined why it shouldn’t be NF kappa B and [TNF]. None of these items are good. He mentioned that the NF kappa B and [TNF] is additional up. In order that signifies that every thing downstream [is] dependent, so that you don’t know which is [which]. The [CRP] is additional down, and the interleukin is simply barely above.

When he mentioned that, I went again to all our research that we did [on] interleukin-6, and so they systematically dropped. And once we studied, we simply tritely mentioned, “You see? It additionally incorporates irritation.” However this isn’t what Professor Ridker mentioned. He mentioned that this interleukin-6 is essential. So I need to inform the viewers right here [that] generally I do one thing, [and] I haven’t totally received the foggiest thought why I [do it]. I did that as a result of I genuinely [knew] it was irritation, after which any person informed me and I regarded. So there isn’t any approach I can contrive to make my quantity humorous. I’m simply doing it. I’m hoping that in science, if my identify leads to anywhere sometime once I’m lengthy gone, I gave my finest shot. And if it really works, then I ought to let the world know. It’s very pleasing for me to seek out out I did this and any person else says later that this interleukin-6 is hand in glove with [CRP]. So irritation is essential [and] fingers down, tocotrienol will cut back irritation.

Chris Kresser:   That’s nice as a result of that was one among my questions that I had written down. As a result of we check interleukin-6 and [CRP] on each affected person [who] comes into our clinic, and I did see adjustments in each of these markers with tocotrienol. So I used to be going to ask you when you’d really studied that as a result of I didn’t see it within the eBook. Nice. Let’s speak about that.

Barrie Tan:   By the best way, the explanation I didn’t put it within the eBook is as a result of I did it, however I didn’t realize it was so essential. However now in my subsequent [publication], I’ll put it in there.

Advantages of Tocotrienols on Most cancers Prevention and Remedy

Chris Kresser:  I need to speak about most cancers. All the opposite advantages we’ve talked about to this point are superb in and of themselves. However the results on most cancers are maybe probably the most thrilling potential scientific functions of tocotrienols, for thus many causes. Perhaps we may begin with mechanisms. And I perceive these aren’t all totally understood but. We talked earlier within the present about tocotrienols’ capacity to inhibit the HMG-CoA reductase enzyme. And that’s, after all, the pathway for ldl cholesterol manufacturing and CoQ10. Nevertheless it performs a novel function in most cancers, too, the place most cancers can hijack that enzyme to unfold ldl cholesterol by means of the tumor and make it worse. It’s been found that tocotrienols have an effect on that enzyme, and which may be one of many mechanisms by which they influence most cancers threat.

Barrie Tan:   There are numerous mechanisms like cell signaling. I nearly don’t need to settle for them as a result of they’re very main the place the nucleus [makes] some type of signaling, and you will note an entire lot of this printed [on] tocotrienol. [There are] two that I maintain [a] sturdy pillar to. One, you talked about, [is] ldl cholesterol. Within the making of any cell, together with most cancers cells, they’ve cell partitions. And [the] cell wall incorporates the very best content material of ldl cholesterol in an effort to get the fluidity and the motion of the cell. If you take tocotrienol, [it] controls the inner construction of the cell membrane by controlling the synthesis of the de novo ldl cholesterol. In order that’s it, as a result of it controls that. A number of authors have printed on this, [and] I can ship you these papers as evaluate papers.

One other time I can clarify how that can also be critically essential for the an infection of COVID[-19]. It’s a must to [do] one other interview [with] me. It’s a very tantalizing subject the place the doorway of the [COVID-19] virus can also be by means of lipid [rafts] that [are] lined with ldl cholesterol, however that’s one other subject [for] one other time.

Chris Kresser:  Okay.

Barrie Tan:  In order that’s one main mechanism. The opposite mechanism can be when the most cancers is multiple millimeter in diameter. When you’ve that, a tiny tumor is shaped. When the tiny tumor is shaped, they need to have a corporation to convey vitamins to it. They can not simply by osmosis suck vitamins from elsewhere. With the intention to try this, it’s a plumbing job. They drill a gap in a close-by artery and make [an] synthetic artery and feed to itself. That course of is [called] angiogenesis. “Genesis,” new, [and] “angio” means artery, to convey [a] new artery into it. And one technique to kill most cancers is anti-angiogenesis. In different phrases, you create a system to cut off the feeding tube to the tumor, and, whether it is wired to develop like a dinosaur, it could additionally die like a dinosaur quick if it doesn’t have the meals. And tocotrienol is among the most potent anti-angiogenic brokers. So the 2 mechanisms can be the stifling of the ldl cholesterol that you simply talked about and the flexibility of the tocotrienol to carry out anti-angiogenesis on the tumor itself. These are the 2 main causes [it goes] after most cancers.

Chris Kresser:  That’s fascinating. I do know from my very own analysis and your e book [that] there are anti-clotting and anti-tumor results; tocotrienols can inhibit circulating most cancers cells, that are liable for recurrence and relapse of most cancers, [and] they’ve been proven to advertise chemosensitization, which might make chemotherapy work higher when sufferers have to have it. There are particular research exhibiting advantages in recurring ovarian most cancers and that tocotrienols might inhibit alerts that estrogen sends to breast most cancers cells. So there could possibly be a profit there in estrogen-positive breast cancers.

So many thrilling issues to discover when it comes to the influence on most cancers cells. Let’s discuss a little bit bit about how individuals can make the most of tocotrienols. One factor that’s essential to clarify is that, sadly, there should not actually any adequate dietary sources of delta- and gamma-tocotrienol. In contrast to another compounds that we examine for these varieties of advantages that you’ll find in vital quantities in meals, [with] delta- and gamma-tocotrienols, it’s not like we will simply eat extra apples or strawberries or one thing and get a therapeutic dose of tocotrienol.

Methods to Finest Make the most of Tocotrienols

Barrie Tan:   By way of a protocol, I’d say this. To set the baseline, I did a examine one time to attempt to learn the way a lot, in a typical American weight-reduction plan, we in all probability get. [We probably get] as much as however not more than 5 milligrams of tocotrienol in our weight-reduction plan. That’s considerably comparable [but] rather less than, tocopherol, which I discussed [is] about 10 to fifteen milligrams. Except somebody eats numerous palm oil, after which there [are] ideas that individuals might not need a lot saturated fats from palm oil. Even in South America, [if] you are taking numerous annatto, then you definately would possibly doubtlessly have the ability to get about 10 to fifteen milligrams tops. So 5 milligrams or much less is what we anticipate. I’d say if an individual is wholesome [and] you haven’t any different situation of any type in any way, no household historical past of this and that, [then] in all probability 100 to 200 milligrams [of] tocotrienol as antioxidant safety will likely be sufficient. How did I give you that? We got here up with that once we studied wholesome aged [people]. We gave them 125 milligrams [of tocotrienol] and measured [their] MDA, methylmalonic acid, after which we measured the antioxidant standing, after which the [CRP], and we seen that they had been good for people who find themselves 60, 65 years previous. In any other case, [nothing] occurred to them.

Then [with] a light persistent situation from pre-diabetes to diabetes, or a household historical past of breast most cancers [or] different most cancers, or [being] obese, or one thing like that, or excessive triglycerides, [then] 200 to 400 milligrams would do it primarily based on a scientific examine. It will be solely on malignancy and issues like that, which we’ve got proven in research [on] individuals with pancreatic most cancers and positively ovarian most cancers [that are] printed. The opposite three not but printed are colon most cancers, lung most cancers, and breast most cancers. I’m holding my breath when they are going to be printed, within the subsequent 12 to 24 months. [They’ll] in all probability come again suggesting someplace between 400 [and] 600 milligrams. Bear in mind, they’re that top as a result of they’re already malignant adjustments. It’s a little bit totally different, [although] sure, it’s a persistent situation of types. So you’ve 100 to 200 milligrams [for] regular antioxidant safety [and] 200 to 400 for a few of these milder circumstances chronically. Normally, it’s a dysmetabolism of your metabolites in your physique. Metabolic syndrome, in different phrases. After which 400 to 600 milligrams on malignancy varieties.

Chris Kresser:   Implausible. And I do know at these larger doses, it’s essential to do a divided dose the place you don’t need to exceed 300 milligrams per meal as a result of the absorption gained’t be nearly as good as when you took it in multiple dose.

Barrie Tan:  Sure, thanks, Chris. I do know that you simply [will] fill within the blanks for me, which I wrote within the e book, however generally I communicate so quick I overlook.

Chris Kresser:  That’s okay. I’m a clinician, too, so I’m at all times fascinated with how individuals really do issues.

Barrie Tan:   Yeah, thanks. I’d say that as a result of tocotrienol is a lipid, simply take it with a meal. An excellent one-half of will probably be absorbed simply by making the most of the emulsification and your bile salts that add collectively and take in it. Don’t take tocotrienol that’s beforehand emulsified, notably with [a] artificial. In the event you put [it with an] synthetic artificial, after all, it’s going to soak up. However I don’t need to try this. I need to make the most of my physique, with just one exception. In case your viewers has malabsorption, [maybe] as a result of their gallbladder [was] taken out, or they [otherwise] have a dysfunction of the fatty acid metabolism, then, in that case, you could have to take it with a teaspoon of MCT, [or] a phospholipid like lecithin. You are able to do that. However in any other case, for the conventional viewers, simply take [it] merely with a meal. That will likely be simply superb.

Chris Kresser:  I need to let all people know who’s listening, you could have heard the announcement [that] I’m launching my very own complement line known as Adapt Naturals in July. It’s going to function a set of merchandise which can be designed [for] what I feel just about all people wants to advertise optimum well being and longevity. And also you gained’t be stunned, Dr. Tan, to study that tocotrienols are going to be part of that stack.

Barrie Tan:  Wow, thanks. Thanks.

Chris Kresser:  So, once I considered vitamins like that, [which] have unbelievable advantages throughout a large spectrum of inflammatory circumstances, and we haven’t even had an opportunity to get into mind well being and prevention of dementia and Alzheimer’s [disease] and bone well being and post-menopausal girls and safety towards radiation publicity and immune well being and all the opposite issues, we’ll need to do a component two. To try this in a approach with a substance that has actually no recognized contraindications, that doesn’t have uncomfortable side effects, that doesn’t put you at larger threat for one thing else when you complement with it over an extended time period. In my 15 years of doing this work, I haven’t come throughout many compounds that match these standards. So, I’m undoubtedly going to be together with this, and we’ll have extra details about this complement stack and how one can make the most of tocotrienols within the close to future. So all people, keep tuned for extra on that.

Dr. Tan, you’re a wealth of information. I need to salute you and thanks on your pioneering work on tocotrienols. I’ve already benefited [from them] as a clinician, and I’ve been in a position to assist so many individuals with every thing from lipid abnormalities to metabolic points to different inflammatory circumstances utilizing tocotrienols. So I simply need to personally thanks on your contribution on this space and would like to have you ever again for half two. I do know we chatted about [geranylgeraniol] as a possible subject, after which when the research on most cancers that you simply talked about are printed, I’d love to talk with you concerning the outcomes of these, as nicely.

Barrie Tan:   Thanks a lot. If we had been to do that in one other 12 months or so, even on tocotrienol, we’ve got a two-year-long examine on women and men with weight problems, which has carried numerous burden, and we gave them tocotrienol. We’re ending up a fatty liver illness examine [that was] 12 months lengthy. After which the third [study is] the most cancers examine. So the tocotrienol is worthy of us [talking about] that. The [geranylgeraniol] one is simply dramatic, [but] I don’t need to add something as a result of we don’t have the time right here. The [geranylgeraniol] one clearly is for the synthesis of menaquinone-4, CoQ10, and muscle. Muscle for myopathy, for individuals who take statins, and muscle for the aged who’ve [a] lack of muscle mass like sarcopenia. These are large points that [geranylgeraniol] can mitigate. I’m so grateful you gave me the possibility to speak. I like to come back on and [be] in a position to present the knowledge. So it’s a blessing to you and I and in addition to the viewers that can hear this. Thanks a lot for inviting me.

Chris Kresser:  Completely. Thanks for becoming a member of me, and thanks [to] all of the listeners for listening. Preserve sending your inquiries to ChrisKresser.com/podcastquestion, and we’ll discuss to you subsequent time.

This episode of Revolution Well being Radio is sponsored by LMNT.

As a member of our neighborhood, LMNT has a really particular supply for you. Declare your free LMNT Pattern Pack – you solely cowl the price of delivery. Get yours at DrinkLMNT.com/Kresser

You may also like...

Leave a Reply